No B.S. from J.P.: what makes a good teacher?
Student Success Podcast No. 8, Nov. 13, 2013
Today’s Guest: J.P. Cassagnol
Now that he’s about to graduate from college, JP discusses his experiences in K-12 and college and how it all fits together to make him the student and person he is. J.P. cuts through the B.S. with excellent critiques of his K-8 and 9th-12 Catholic education, and what worked, what didn’t and, most importantly, what makes a great teacher. In J.P.’s case, those teachers are Brother Martin and Prof. Carlander, teachers who inspired, pushed, and turned JP into a real student with real learning.
An important challenge J.P. brings to education is his K-8 experience, which he found entirely lacking once he came upon Brother Martin’s 9th grade Honors English class. Are we underserving our K-8 children? And what of those kids who didn’t get into Brother Martin’s class?
J.P. Cassignol is a senior at Salisbury University, Eastern Shore, MD, with a concentration in History. J.P. Graduated from St. John’s College High School in Washington, D.C., and prior to that was enrolled in a Catholic school K-8 program. J.P. loves history and literature, and he works as a tutor in those and other subjects.
- St. Johns College High School: what’s the “college” thing about?
- JP was not prepared for 9th grade
- his K-8 did not prepare him
- never had written anything more than a few paragraphs
- 9th grade: what do kids bring to it?
- why are elementary schools all so different?
- why should 9th grade be so much harder?
- Elementary: seeking universal standards
- JPs 9th grade was challenging
- Big gap between elementary and high school
- are we pushing kids hard enough in K-8?
- “Excellence Gap” study by Dr. Jonathan Plucker
- J.P.’s school competitive?
- Catholic school admissions: an incestual orgy? (lol)
- Public school kids more prepared?
- depends on the demographic
- are outcomes defined by zip codes?
- Rte 50 / Univ Blvd: the dividing lines
- do charter schools drain talent?
- lowest common denominator v. the cream of the crop
- Was his high school worth the money? maybe not
- Would rather have gone to college twice
- But he did go there, it is who he is
- What if he had gone to public school?
- would have lost all the expereinces of a catholic school
- Brother Martin: English teacher
- heavy workload
- read a book a week
- not reading in class… taking turns lol
- depth of analysis that he had never encountered
- English class was no longer about structure, was about literature
- then next year, teacher was back to reading out loud in class
- so teachers matter?
- should any teacher be able to teach anything?
- JPs definition of a good teacher? Hope Brother Martin is listenng to this
- the difference between a teacher who knows everything but can’t teach and a teacher who may not know everything but can teach and lead you to where you need to go
- why do some kids like certain teachers and others not?
- kids look for easy teachers = business major etiquette
- but they won’t remember those teachers
- a good assignment is powerful
- has assignments from high school that he still thinks about
- Bromley’s best teacher: Prof Wright who threatened to fail him Senior year of college: 1st teacher who ever “kicked my ass”
- Dr. Carlander at Salisbury: they’d get into for 3 hours .. he’d rip up his paper … they’d argue with each other.. inspiring!
- always read the prof’s book!
- knows his stuff: and “a real teacher”
- Prof got JP to write a grant application: got it & went to a national conference >> all because of a real teacher
- What make a good teacher:
- learning is supposed to be rigorous
- “no pressure no diamond”
- teachers who earned respect, who mentor, who respect kids
- unlike teachers who just put notes on the board
- good teachers: challenge, drag, empower
- learning is a fight! “I’m a 13 year old kid, what do I give a shit about Julius Caesar?”
- You could see it in Brother Martin’s brow lines … but patient and caring … loved his students
Host: Michael L. Bromley
Original Music by Christopher Bromley (copyright 2011, 2013)
Background snoring: by Stella
Best Dogs Ever: by Puck & Stella
Happy dogs with new beds!
Here for Puck & Stella slideshow
The A+ Club from School4Schools.com LLC, based in Arlington, VA, is dedicated to helping students across the U.S.A. meet their goals and find the academic success the want and deserve. Contact us here or call now to (703) 271-5334 to see how we can help.